The Pillow Talk Suite is a mid-century love letter to romance, wit, and two-party lines. It’s a retreat for the urban sophisticate that captures effervescence, playful tension, and undeniable glamour of the classic romantic comedy.
This suite includes a private patio, kitchenette with lofted ceilings, a mini fridge, and microwave. Off the kitchen is a full bedroom and bathroom. The adjacent living area has a pull-out sofa, coffee table, chairs, flat-screen TV with streaming, and electric fireplace that that sets the tone for cozy evenings.
The Pillow Talk Suite is a vibrant stage set for your own story of connection, designed with a wink and the spirit of Jan Morrow and Brad Allen.

Highly recommend – outstanding! Proximate to dining and recreation. Highly recommend.
Absolutely amazing! I loved the place and wish I could come back soon!
We loved this place! It was cute, clean, and cozy. The vintage design was charming and everything was so clean. Terese was responsive, and checking in was so easy. Lake Geneva is a magical place, and Williams Bay is our favorite town to stay in when we visit. I highly recommend staying in one of Terese’s places.
A really comfortable room in a lovely little community. Great value!!! We would definitely come back.
I stayed with my boyfriend in the Pillow Talk room for a family weekend wedding and it was outstanding! No joke, our family members were actually kinda jealous when they saw the pictures, lol! I love the movie pillow talk (I designed my house to be like Doris Day’s apartment in the movie) and this perfectly emulated the retro style of that movie. A 3 minutewalk to food and coffee, and a super close walk to ice cream and the lake. I would absolutely stay here again and try some of the other rooms.
This room was beautiful. The bathroom has been remodeled and is gorgeous. The bed was very comfortable. I highly recommend this location and host.
Enter your dates above to see available rooms and pricing.
No rooms are available for those dates.
Try adjusting your check-in or check-out date.
Your Details
The American Hotel is 100% smoke, vape, and flame-free. A $250 cleaning surcharge will be imposed on any room where guests have smoked (including e-cigarettes) or vaped in their room or anywhere on property.
Cancel 5 or more days before check-in for a full 100% refund. Cancellations within 5 days of check-in are non-refundable.
Payment
✓ Free cancellation until 5 days before check-in · ✓ Confirmation emailed instantly
🔒 Payments secured by Stripe · A quick photo-ID check follows payment
Verify Your Identity
The American Hotel requires a valid government-issued ID to complete your reservation. This is handled securely by Stripe and is never stored on our servers.
🔒 Your ID is verified by Stripe and never stored on this site
A confirmation has been sent to your email.
The American Hotel
Be the first to hear about openings, events, and news on Geneva Lake.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.