Discover The Starlight House, where mid-century charm meets modern ease. Step into every room that is thoughtfully outfitted for restful nights. This 3 bed/2.5 bath house provides a well equipped kitchen with modern amenities (stove, microwave, refrigerator, and island). Sophisticated touches throughout ensure a stay as effortless as it is refined. End your day on the rooftop terrace for a glass a wine, a cozy fire, or to read a good book.
This house includes a balcony terrace, full stocked kitchen, a refrigerator, and microwave. Off the kitchen is a half bathroom. The adjacent living area has a couch, coffee table, chairs, flat-screen TV with streaming
This home is your new lake house.
We had a great weekend! Terese was a great host – very responsive and friendly. Her place was adorably decorated, stylish, and extremely clean. The space was spacious and in a great location. Thank you!!
We had such a blast! We walked around town, went to the beach, and ended every night at The Frosty Moose. Thank you for letting us stay in your beautiful home. We will be back!
We had a wonderful, relaxing time once again at “The American”. The indoor and outdoor spaces are beautiful! We will be back
We had a great stay here – thank you! We loved getting ice cream from The Frosty Moose and eating it on the balcony. We had some great walks by the lake and had a lovely meal at Harpoon Willies. The beach is wonderful – thank you for the pass!
Thank you for such lovely accommodations. This was the perfect place and space to unwind, relax, and celebrate!
We had a blast having our bachelorette party here! Home was wonderful as well as the location! Thank you for hosting us!
Thank you very much for the beautiful, super clean and charming accommodations! We really enjoyed our stay! Both of our kids wanted to stay longer and want to come back. Our 4-year old said – this house is so nice and amazing! I couldn’t agree more! Thank you.
Thank you for the lovely accommodations! This was the perfect place to unwind and relax during our girls’ weekend trip. Cute and cozy. Would definitely stay again.
We really enjoyed our stay - My wife and I went up with my son his wife and grandson. It was perfect - even the grandson who is 2 1/2 didn’t want to leave - he said goodbye lake house - see you soon. It is like a home from home. Thank you so much for sharing your house with us.
We enjoyed our stay in this beautifully renovated house. It was a great location for walking to see the lake and great restaurants. Terese was great at answering all my questions prior to our stay.
Terese's place was very clean and nicely decorated. The 3rd 1/2 bath was perfect for 2 friends staying several days allowing for private baths and a shared bathroom off the main living space. We especially enjoyed the 2nd level outside patio w comfy furniture and gas firepit. The location is good-small grocery across the street with restaurants and beach/path within walking distance. Lake Geneva is a short easy drive offering shopping and dining options. The unit next door is under construction and during the day and into the evening there was work going on. There are also tenants living in other units on the property. We enjoyed our stay. Once this property is completely renovated it would be a great place for a larger group, like a family reunion or wedding party to stay!
We very much enjoyed our stay. The accommodations were excellent. The bed was comfortable. It was hot during our stay, but the air conditioners did a great job of cooling the place, such that there were times we were fine without them. The kitchen was well appointed. Two and 1/4 baths was very handy. Very close to the Lake Geneva walking path which we enjoyed.
Enter your dates above to see available rooms and pricing.
No rooms are available for those dates.
Try adjusting your check-in or check-out date.
Your Details
The American Hotel is 100% smoke, vape, and flame-free. A $250 cleaning surcharge will be imposed on any room where guests have smoked (including e-cigarettes) or vaped in their room or anywhere on property.
Cancel 5 or more days before check-in for a full 100% refund. Cancellations within 5 days of check-in are non-refundable.
Payment
✓ Free cancellation until 5 days before check-in · ✓ Confirmation emailed instantly
🔒 Payments secured by Stripe · A quick photo-ID check follows payment
Verify Your Identity
The American Hotel requires a valid government-issued ID to complete your reservation. This is handled securely by Stripe and is never stored on our servers.
🔒 Your ID is verified by Stripe and never stored on this site
A confirmation has been sent to your email.
The American Hotel
Be the first to hear about openings, events, and news on Geneva Lake.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.